Best Choices for Italian Dining in New Castle, PA

New Castle, Pennsylvania is a beautiful location to visit, experience great food and perhaps, even move to one day depending on your needs. There are many Italian restaurants you must try in New Castle when you are in the town. Continue reading below to learn more about the top 10 Italian restaurants in New Castle.

Pagley’s Italian Restaurant

1235 E Washington St, New Castle, PA 16101

Pagley’s Italian Restaurant is one of the most authentic locations that you can visit, especially when considering that they serve both calamari and smelt. This restaurant also has an expansive drink menu so that you are sure to be entertained during your dinner. Do not worry though, as Pagley’s is also kid-friendly.

Chuck Tanner’s Restaurant

2305 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105

Every meal that is made at Chuck Tanner’s Restaurant is made from scratch. This includes steaks, lamb, meats of any kind, fresh seafood, delicious pasta, gravies and so much more. You will find that every staff member truly cares about their customers as well so that you have your meal in a comfortable environment where you are taken care of from start to finish.

II Tomato

2409 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105

II Tomato offers fresh ingredients so that you can taste the truest flavors of Italy with every bite. Every entree is made by hand from start to finish, and there are some entrees that are considered antipasti as well. There is an expansive alcohol menu as well so that the whole dinner is brought together, whether you eat in the restaurant or at home.

The Ladies of the Dukes

114 N. Croton Avenue, New Castle, PA 16101

The Ladies of the Dukes has been a popular Italian restaurant in New Castle for over 60 years. They have received many rewards for serving the best Italian food in the city as well. The five Italian women who founded this restaurant are sure to bring the best Italian recipes so that you can experience the country through food. Please note they are only open on Sundays.

Mangino’s Pizza

2710 Wilmington Rd

106 N Liberty St, New Castle, PA 16102

Charles Jr. and Johanna Mangine started this restaurant in 1979, over 40 years ago and now have two locations. The pizza crust that is used at the restaurant is homemade and hand-pinched. Even the sauce contains special spices that are secret in a way so that your mouth is left watering.

Gallo’s Italian Villa

2420 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105

Gallo’s Italian Villa has both lunch and dinner options for your Italian needs. There is even a bar available at this restaurant that serves specialties, beers, and wines to best meet your needs. For the past 13 years, this restaurant has been voted as the best Italian restaurant in the town of New Castle.

Soni’s Italian Restaurant

3209 Wilmington Rd, New Castle, PA 16105

Soni’s Italian Restaurant has something on the menu that everyone can enjoy, including healthy options, gluten-free options, and vegetarian options. There are party tray and catering options available for anyone who needs large portions as well. Finally, be sure to finish your dinner with a great dessert as well.

Pizza Man’s Pizza

9 S Jefferson St, New Castle, PA 16101

Pizza Man’s Pizza is a relatively new restaurant in New Castle as it was just opened in 2010. Every piece of dough is handmade at the restaurant, in which they also make every soup from scratch. You will find numerous toppings for your pizzas to make it your own as well for your family to enjoy.

Turco’s Pizza Inside of The VeniSei Winery

Turco’s Pizza | 1409 Wilson Ave., New Castle, PA 16101

This fantastic pizza place specializes in its very own unique style of pizza known as “Pan Fried Sicilian”. It’s so good that they take pre-orders on Fridays & Sundays. Be sure to stop in and taste how amazing this place really is.

Disilvio’s Restaurant in New Castle

100 West Washington Street New Castle Pa

A pleasant family dining atmosphere that offers military discount every day and senior discounts all day on Mondays and Tuesdays. Homestyle, homemade cooking that is made fresh daily. A large variety of menu options that is perfect for any palette.

Final Thoughts

New Castle, Pennsylvania is a great place to find some of the most authentic Italian food that is available in the country. Check out one of the restaurants above to satisfy your Italian cravings, then consider moving to the area so that you can experience these flavors all the time.